Is SIP/NANO that much better than TSR/FG??

xxxc5

xxxc5

New member
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Messages
63
Reaction score
0
It's that time again to polish the Vette for spring/summer. Previously I used TSR/FG with 95% succesful removal of swirls and scratches. I attribute not achieving 100% removal to my undepowered 1st generation Meguiars G100 DA and not using flat pads (5.5 flat pads were not available through Autogeek at the time). I am stepping up my game this time and purchasing a Griots ROP with LC 5.5 flat pads. I ran out of polishes and need to choose either the WG twins or Menzerna SIP/Nano. These two systems are the most widely used combos for Vettes that I have seen here and on the various Vette forums. The Menzerna combo is more than double the cost of the WG twins. I realize it's for double the amount of product (16oz vs 8oz) but was wondering if this incremental increase in cost is really worth it in terms of results, ease of use, time, etc.? Will I be able to achieve perfect results with the WG twins now that I have a more powerful DA? I will be purchasing some 085rd regardless as I am very impressed with everything I have read and seen on the forum. In regards to 085rd, I see on the Menzerna chart that it has some cut to it. Is it possible to remove minor swirls and scratches with this and a orange/white pad? Thanks!!
 
Have you considered the M105/205 combo? You can now get those in 8oz bottles and are MUCH cheaper then the other 2 you mention. I can assure you that you will get great results using them.
 
I would also have to agree on the 105/205 combo i feel it works the best on the vettes hard clear coat.Also the 85rd really isn't strong enough for paint correction on corvettes but it works great to finish with and get some really great results with it using it that way.Blue pad and you will be set.Also you may want to do a test spot before you start the whole car that will really tell the direction that you need to go
 
For your vette or any other car you will be using your da on, 105/205/85rd are going to be the best combo.
 
Thanks everybody so far for the input. I'm seeing the Megs 105/205 combo is the general consensus so far. However, I really don't need anything as aggressive as 105. I don't have serious correction to do. Just some leftover scratches from the previous detail and some new scratches. The finish is virtually swirl free. TSR/FG took care of 95% of it. The 5% I didn't was due to an underpowered DA and CCS pads. TSR/FG was aggressive enough. I just tired out from the continuous extra amount of pressure I had to use with the underpowered DA. Megs 105 is a heavy compound rating in at #9 in terms of aggressiveness on the Autogeek Compound Chart as oppossed to #6. I'm just curious why such an aggressive compound would be suggested for light to medium duty correction?
 
TSR and FG are close enough to SIP/Nano IMO. You could add 085rd for jeweling as desired.
 
105 is aggressive, but, still finishes out nicely. It has become my go to polish even for minor swirls. It does the job quickly without creating too much marring. Since it is a SMAT product, you dont have to work it until it is broken down. This allows you to quit when the swirls are gone without removing too much paint. If in doubt, try the 8 oz bottles of it. Do a test section and see what you think. I seriously doubt you will be disappointed.

btw, love your vette. One of my favorite Special Edition Vettes.
 
xxxc5 said:
Thanks everybody so far for the input. I'm seeing the Megs 105/205 combo is the general consensus so far. However, I really don't need anything as aggressive as 105. I don't have serious correction to do. Just some leftover scratches from the previous detail and some new scratches. The finish is virtually swirl free. TSR/FG took care of 95% of it. The 5% I didn't was due to an underpowered DA and CCS pads. TSR/FG was aggressive enough. I just tired out from the continuous extra amount of pressure I had to use with the underpowered DA. Megs 105 is a heavy compound rating in at #9 in terms of aggressiveness on the Autogeek Compound Chart as oppossed to #6. I'm just curious why such an aggressive compound would be suggested for light to medium duty correction?
Click to expand...

Here is the thing with 105, you change the cut by the type of pad you use. So if you have four different pads you actually have four different type of cuts of polish. That is the beauty of having the Megs twins. The only down fall is that 205 needs to be followed up to really amp up the finish. Also 105 isn't as aggressive as people make it out to be.

I would not blame the da or you ccs pads for not being able to remove the last 5% of your defects but blame the polishes you had. You even said yourself that you had to use a lot of effort and that was from the polishes not being able to handle your defects. Get yourself some 105and 205 and you will see how much easier it will be to remove your defects.
 
I find on Corvettes, most of the time they need to be wooled with Menzerna Power Gloss. Unfortunately, the fiberglass bodied cars don't heat up like metal bodied cars, and require heavy polishing. Best of luck.


John
 
I had a black C5 Corvette at Detail Fest that the owner brought into the new detail bay and used Wolfgang TSR with the Porter Cable and removed 95% of the swirls so that only the deeper RIDS were left in the paint.

Did this moving the DA very slowly and giving the pad/product/oscillating action plenty of time to work or abrade the paint. I might have used a polishing pad too but off-hand I don't remember.

Of course more aggressive products will do the job faster, in this case the owner had never used a machine before and wanted something that would be easy for a beginner to use without making any mistakes.

M105 was introduced after M86 and M86 was Meguiar's version of System One, which was for all practical purposes, the product that made popular the idea of a one liquid system where you use the same chemical or liquid and adjust the pad to make the product more or less aggressive.

This idea works with M86, D151, M205 and actually any product that abrades it's just with SMAT products you can stop anytime in the process because you don't have to wait for the abrasives to break down since the abrasives in SMAT products don't break down like DAT products.


For more information on SMAT products, check out these to article,

The SMAT Pack - Everything you ever wanted to know about Meguiar's SMAT products...



Also, Ultimate Compound is a VERY capable compound almost as aggressive as M105 and most people find it a lot more user friendly with a DA Polisher than M105.


The Aggressiveness Order of SMAT Products - This might surprise you!
SMATaggressivenessOrder.jpg



I've posted this before and here it is again, I was hoping at SEMA/NACE last year Meguiar's was going to introduce a new and improved version of M105 but they didn't, that said I'm confident they're aware of the feed back people post about short buffing cycle, dusting and difficulty in removal in some environments. It also could be if the product is improved it will be a formula tweak with no fanfare.

The only time I've personally had any problem with M105 was in the middle of summer in very hot and dry heat in horrible working conditions, other than that I've had good luck with it.


:)
 
Mike, if I remember correctly you were using a white polishing pad on the C6. The owner even stated it was a night and day difference.


detailjohn said:
I find on Corvettes, most of the time they need to be wooled with Menzerna Power Gloss. Unfortunately, the fiberglass bodied cars don't heat up like metal bodied cars, and require heavy polishing. Best of luck.


John
Click to expand...

I recently heard a story of a C6 Vette panel getting so hot that an ice pack was used to cool the area and steam was rolling off....:buffing:
 
rwright said:
Mike, if I remember correctly you were using a white polishing pad on the C6. The owner even stated it was a night and day difference.

You are correct, that was a C6.


I recently heard a story of a C6 Vette panel getting so hot that an ice pack was used to cool the area and steam was rolling off....:buffing:
Click to expand...

I wonder who that was?Im the MAN
 
Wow! I thought SwirlX was less abrasive than M205. Very insteresting.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top