Thanks for all the replies....now I have even more choices than before. The photos of that Poorboys a couple posts up look like what I want, just a matte. But I looked at photos of the two I already bought and they look much glossier in person.
Looks like I got some testing and money wasting...
ugh....lots of opinions I have to spend money on and try I guess.
I am going to recommend autogeek test each dressing and make a chart of matte to gloss and put them in order or at least put them in categories so people quit asking what is gloss or matte. I'm sure they will care less.
I have...
So, I read for hours and thought I made the right choice. I picked Opti-Bond.
It went on weird, it kept evaporating away or looked like it was not staying on 100% coverage and separating. Two year old tires that have never had dressing on them (truck I tried for a sample). After three coats...