Biggest Wax Test Ever - Detailing World

[tWiStEd-tORqUe]

Really awsome test i found on DW

Thread Owner : Finerdetails
Source: Biggest Wax Test Ever - Detailing World

Its taken some time in the making, and waiting for time allowance and the right day of weather hasn't helped things either.

What I would like to start by doing, is to start by thanking those persons who have helped me in this mission.

Jon - Epoch
Alex - Serious Performance
Ben - Rubbish Boys
Dom - Dodo
Mike - mickeystman
Rob - Gleam machine
Brian - Drive n Shine
Dom - Meguiars

What these guys help me to do was put together the following for this test:

Swissvax Divine
Swissvax Mystery
Swissvax Best of Show
Swissvax Concourso
Swissvax Saphir
Swissvax Onyx
***** Royale
***** Vintage
***** Glasur
***** Carbon
Collinite 845IW
Collinite 915
Collinite 476s
Nattys Blue
Nattys White
Rubbish Boys Orginal
Rubbish Boys Dodo Juice
Dodo Super Natural
Dodo Blue Velvet
Dodo Purple Haze
Dodo Rainforest Rub
Vic Concours (red)
Autoglym High Definition Wax
Finish Klare Pink Wax
Espuma Revive
Autosmart Cherry Glaze
Meguiars NXT

First job was to get the horsbox washed with Activo:

Next job was to clean and prep the paint, using Duraseal and an MF pad. ALL done by hand!

Once the prep was done it was time to start marking out some test beds:

Each wax applied with a clean foam pad. Each wax left for 30mins to cure. Each wax removed with a clean MF cloth.

Tape removed and glue lines left:

I have deliberately left the tape gaps and lines to help differentiate the areas for each wax. I aim to be checking the durability at the start of each month. I may even take a DW NW member on each occasion as witness.

And final full scale shots:

Not a bad afternoon's graft!

Best subscribe to this thread so you dont misss the updates!

Update 26.7.08

Well I finally got round to getting back and checking up on progress. Not the best day with the heat, but at least it wasn't doing the massive big fat rain we have had sooo much of since I applied all the waxes.

The waxes have now been in place for one month. Pics of dusty Horsebox:

I firstly gave the area a rinse with the P/W before spraying a layer of Ph Neutral Snowfoam over for washing:

Then rinsed off and checked the various sections as I did:

A reminder of what is where:

So any has happened?

Both Autosmart Cherry Glaze and the Espuma Revive have all but failed. There is some evidence of some remianing protection, but not enough that I could tell a csutomer their car had wax on it. We have our first two drop outs. This, if I am being honest, is exactly what I expected to see and thus confirms the rpogress to date and planned approach of comparing on the same panel area.

The rest of the waxes are all much of a muchness, and will need more time to see how they perform. This is with the exception of three waxes awhich displayed a lessing level and I feel will be shown up at the next update end of August time.

Updated Start of Sept 08
Through July we have had some mega weather, huge downpours, then bright sunshine, great fot he pushing of the LSps and the waxes to test their determination against the elements.

Some before pics:

Then washed and rinsed off. We now have a huge noticable area where a group of waxes have all failed:

So, lets confirm the state of play after two months.

Month one saw Revive and Cherry Glaze drop out - as expected and so no shocks.
This month we have said goodbye to:
Finish Kare Pink Wax
NXT Liquid
Dodo Blue Velvet
Dodo Rainforest Rub, and
Dodo Supernatural.

I have to say, I am completely shocked and would not have put any of these four to fail at the two month stage. Lets see what the next month brings!

Iain

slightly later than I would have hoped, but FD commitments must come first!

So, 8.10.08 - end ish of month three.

Drop outs? None to speak of.
On the being watched very carefully list as things aint looking too healthy:

1- Nattys White
2- Nattys Blue
3 - AG HD wax
4- Swissvax Onyx
and.....

5- Collinite 476s!! I'm gob smacked to say the least!

Lets see what end of Oct brings, I will try to be on track next time

review number 4!

Test start date 30.6.08. Reviews taken at 26.7.08, 1.9.08, 8.10.08 and today 1.11.08.

Over the months I've watched these waxes moving and doing their work, and I was kinda hoping we'd be slowing down with numbers by now, the weather has become harder, so I'm finding time and effort more difficult. But, on with the show!

Drop outs? no, we are still seeing protection from those remianing, although I have seen an increase in the number of waxes which must be watched very carefully at the next review. These include:

NXT Paste wax
Victoria Concours
Nattys white
Nattys Blue
Z Royale
Z Glasur
Z Carbon
Swissvax Onyx
Swissvax Saphir.

All wxes now stand at four months durability.

I have watched the Nattys and Onyx from last month when they entered my watch list and they have deteriorated slightly, but are still protected for now.

12.1.09

OK guys, time has pasted, we have seen one of the coldest and longest periods of weather since 1986, apparently.....

Review, 12th January 2009:

The last review was start of Nov, and today was a huge task just to wash the horsebox, I used over 175 litres!

Test orignally started 30th June 2008. Reviews took place at 26th July, 1st Spet, 8th Oct and 1st Nov 2008.

After 6 and 1/2 months, the following waxes are still protecting the paintwork:

Autoglym Hi Def
Collinite 915 Marque D'Elegance
Nattys White & Blue
RaceGlaze 55
Swissvax Divine, Mystery, BoS and Concourso
Victoria Concours
***** Vintage and Glasur

So there you have it, my final list of what lasted over six months in very extreme conditions too.

I am sorry to say I shall not be conducting any further reviews, the time is no longer available. Due to the amopunt of failures and the appearance of the horsebox there is also now a need to get it all stripped back and restored to its previous glory.

Thank you to everyone who has followed this, and I hope it has proved as useful to you, as it has to me.

 

[Mirror Detailing]

Always cool to see alot of the cheaper waxes out lasting the more expensive waxes!

 

[OCDetails]

I would have loved to see Souveran, S100/P21S, and Fuzion in on that test. I'd put Fuzion up against any of those waxes for durability.

 

[Mike PhillipsMike Phillips is verified member.]

I think tests like these are great!

But... each person is different and each person still has to find a product they like and the only way to find out if you like a product is to buy it and try it yourself on your car's specific paint and the conditions and environment that your car's paint is exposed to...

Test like these are a great guide as to what someone else discovered so use it as a guide but after doing you're research it's time to start your own testing on your own car...


Start here...


Autogeek's complete selection of waxes and paint sealants


You work hard, so treat yourself to a present once in a while and try something new!

Or send the above link to family and friends with hints as to which ones you're curios about when it comes to your birthday!



:dblthumb2:

 

[Misha]

very nice. i have 2 of final waxes. one of them i got couse of this review

he didnt say nothing about ROBE durability but looks like its holding up

 

[Showroom Shine]

I would have loved to see Souveran, S100/P21S, and Fuzion in on that test. I'd put Fuzion up against any of those waxes for durability.

:iagree:I too would LOVE to have seen the Souveran Paste or liquid tested with the more expensive waxes!

 

[TLMitchell]

When I first spied the subject line for this thread I thought it was referencing another wax test seen on DW. Dave KG, DW's resident guru, and associates, prepped 7 identical cars in an effort to determine the differences, if any, between high-dollar LSPs and the more moderately priced. Makes for interesting reading:

Big Wax Test - Looks Results - Full Review - Detailing World

The results and conclusions were very interesting as well:

Wax Test - The Looks Results!! - Detailing World

Big Wax Test - Beading & Sheeting - HAVE YOUR SAY! - Detailing World

My Conclusion on The Wax Test Results - Detailing World

To paraphrase, some conclude that spending a fortune of boutique waxes is a waste of money as looks are nearly imperceptible and longevity has nothing to do with price. Makes me want to run right out and pick up some Crystal Rock <NOT!>

Mike espouses a much better criteria to selecting LSPs:

"Find something you like and use it often."

TL

 

[agpatel]

When I first spied the subject line for this thread I thought it was referencing another wax test seen on DW. Dave KG, DW's resident guru, and associates, prepped 7 identical cars in an effort to determine the differences, if any, between high-dollar LSPs and the more moderately priced. Makes for interesting reading:

Big Wax Test - Looks Results - Full Review - Detailing World

The results and conclusions were very interesting as well:

Wax Test - The Looks Results!! - Detailing World

Big Wax Test - Beading & Sheeting - HAVE YOUR SAY! - Detailing World

My Conclusion on The Wax Test Results - Detailing World

To paraphrase, some conclude that spending a fortune of boutique waxes is a waste of money as looks are nearly imperceptible and longevity has nothing to do with price. Makes me want to run right out and pick up some Crystal Rock <NOT!>

Mike espouses a much better criteria to selecting LSPs:

"Find something you like and use it often."

TL

That was a great review that Dave did and really showed there there are small differences on a well prepped paint. But the search for the best LSP will for me personally never be done even if I find something I like I will want to try something different, haha.

One thing also to take not of the two reviews in this thread where from the UK, different conditions than we have in the states and thus YMMV.

 

[Bradshaw]

Natty's Blue at 6 months? Things that make you say Hmmmmm

 

[Gary Sword]

Besides protection everyone's hoping a wax or sealant will add that litte something extra to make their paint standout. One thing for sure is a well prepped swirl free jeweled paint looks great with nothing on it and will still look great with just about any wax or sealant on it.

 

[fubar]

Found this site that they tested alot of products check it out.

Car Care: Expert Reviews & Rankings | Bestcovery

 

[Misha]

^^ ill call it BS. where is tests and where is list of products tested and from what was best waxes i wouldnt trust that that much, but thats just me and my opinion

 

[fubar]

^^ ill call it BS. where is tests and where is list of products tested and from what was best waxes i wouldnt trust that that much, but thats just me and my opinion

I have no idea just thought it was interesting when i came across this info. figure i would share this with everyone.

 

[Bradshaw]

Problem is, that RV looks like Gel Coat, which isn't the same as regular clear coated paint. And there is just no way you are pulling 6 months off Nattys Blue, no way. I wouldn't put alot of stock in the results.

 

[agpatel]

Problem is, that RV looks like Gel Coat, which isn't the same as regular clear coated paint. And there is just no way you are pulling 6 months off Nattys Blue, no way. I wouldn't put alot of stock in the results.

Some issues that were raised in the thread were how the position of the wax on the side of the RV effected durability, also oils from other waxing mixing with wax's that were below it may of hurt performance. Bottom line is that it was pretty impressive review but like you said you still have to weight what you personally see in durability. Also shows that if you want a durable wax you dont have to look at expensive wax's but a $15 pot of Collinite will outlast most wax's and sealants and still look good.

 

[TLMitchell]

Also shows that if you want a durable wax you dont have to look at expensive wax's but a $15 pot of Collinite will outlast most wax's and sealants and still look good.

:dblthumb2::dblthumb2::dblthumb2::dblthumb2::dblthumb2:

 

[Surfer]

Problem is, that RV looks like Gel Coat, which isn't the same as regular clear coated paint. And there is just no way you are pulling 6 months off Nattys Blue, no way. I wouldn't put alot of stock in the results.

I have gotten 3 months of NB before the protection started noticeably fading, and thats in South FL weather.

Collinite 915 though will outlast any wax and pretty much any sealant. That stuff is magical, don't know what they do... lol