Is BMW paint typically hard or soft? I used Prima Swirl on a Uber Orange pad on my red 92' 325i and removed a lot of oxidation and ligiht scratches and the car looks great. I then moved onto my silver 2000 528i and used the same product and it didn't seen to get the scratches out when under lights.
Mike from Mike@DedicatedPerfection will probably chime in on this.
I'm just throwing this out there as a question, is it possible your 92 325i was single stage paint? I ask because you mention oxidization, and that you corrected it. According to Mike Phillips in a Clear-Coat failure thread, he states, that oxidation on bc/cc paints occur through the entire matrix or thickness of the paint. in other words, if a new(er) bc/cc vehicle exhibits oxidation, it's probably the beginning stages of cc failure. Again just thinking aloud.
One way to test the 92 is take a white applicator with some compound in an inconspicuous spot and buff. If the applicator comes back with color, it's SS.
Lots of variables, probably too many to know between your 1992 and 2000 BMW's on how a product and pad will work with paint. Paints and technology have changed a lot over the last 25 years, and will continue to change with water-based VOC compliant paint.
The best thing I always do is treat every car without a preconceived notion (hard to do on new GM's!), but... Always do a test spot and dial in your product.
You'd be surprised at how one vehicle may react to one combo vs. another.