Orange peel correction, hand vs Pnuematic palm sander (long post)

A4 1.8tqm

New member
Joined
Apr 4, 2009
Messages
1,932
Reaction score
0
Here is some more work I've done on the 1996 BMW 328i that I've mentioned in previous posts.

Wet sanding by hand, a couple weeks ago-

The orange peel on this repainted hood is crazy! Apparently it was sprayed very thick, giving me lots of material to work with (fortunately there wasn't significant Solvent popping, like another panel I sanded). Also it seems that it was not painted in a clean, painting booth environment, from all the dust/nibs i found while claying.

I taped off a section of the hood to do a test spot. The car was washed with citrus wash and clear and clayed before beginning any work.

I started with 800 grit wet/dry paper on a soft sanding block, sanding in straight lines in a side to side motion. This was very aggressive and made quick work of the orange peel. I only sanded to the lowest point of the majority of the orange peel, leaving room for error and for damp sanding with the pneumatic palm sander later on. Then I hit it with 3000 grit paper, I know, I know that's too big of a gap in abrasiveness, well 800 and 3000 is all I had on hand. This time I sanded in straight lines from front to back, alternating the direction between grits really made it easy to tell if the previous sanding marks were removed. It took a LONG time to remove 800 marks with 3000 grit, but I eventually got there. To remove the sanding marks I used Menz Power Gloss on a 6.5" LC Cyan Hydro-tech pad (great combo BTW) onmy Flex 3401. I did not polish any more than this combo, I was amazed how well it finished!

Some pics-
Pneu_DAhood1.jpg


IMG_3993.jpg


IMG_4009.jpg


IMG_4010.jpg


IMG_3997.jpg


IMG_4005.jpg


Now I know I made a lot of extra work for myself by not having the correct selection of sand paper to work with, but I got good results!

On to the Pnuematic palm sander-

Lucky me, my friend wants me to test out all his new goodies! The Viking VT4200w, this little guy is heavy, it feels very well built. I think it's a $250+ tool. We went to Wesco and picked up a 6" Hook-It 1 soft interface pad and a 25 pack of p1500 3M trizact clear coat sanding discs (Love these discs!) I referenced http://www.autogeekonline.net/forum...fing/23865-if-has-paint-gets-polished.htmlfor for the damp sanding technique. Now this palm sander, unlike the Megs DA in Mike's thread, DOES NOT rotate. It just moves in a tiny circular pattern, like you would do with your hand.

The stuff, these pics were taken after doing the work-
Pneu_DA1-1.jpg


Sanding discs-
Pneu_DA6-1.jpg


Loop side of hook-it 1 disc-
Pneu_DA2-1.jpg


Abrasive side, this is after many passes, still look pretty good!
Pneu_DA3-1.jpg


Abrasive close-up, the same used sanding disc-
IMG_4392.jpg


We chose a 6" soft interface pad even though the backing plate is 5", the overhang gives a very soft edge so the paper doesn't dig-in into any body lines.
Pneu_DA4-1.jpg


Barely touching, very soft (not like I'm going to sand at this angle though).
Pneu_DA5-1.jpg


I taped off the edges to be safe-
Pneu_DA1.jpg


Tape line from hand sanding-
Pneu_DA2.jpg


Close-up, orange peel half removed-
Pneu_DA3.jpg


Near the tape line, orange peel removed. these discs give a very uniform finish, I know Menz PG will have no prob here!-

Pneu_DA5.jpg


Edge-
Pneu_DA4.jpg


Tape removed and carefully sanded-
Pneu_DA14.jpg


Pneu_DA13.jpg


Menz PG on Cyan HT, after the initial section pass' (done by my friend Chris) I revived the polish with a light spritz of Pinnacle Pad Lube and re-polished it myself until it flashed clear-
Pneu_DA8.jpg


Pneu_DA10.jpg


The Marring free finish I got after the second pass was astounding!

Pneu_DA11.jpg


Pneu_DA12.jpg


Pneu_DA15.jpg


Pneu_DA16.jpg


I used flaws in the paint to help get manual focus, PG finishes swirl/marring free?
Pneu_DA17.jpg


Pneu_DA18.jpg


Pneu_DA19.jpg


There's some marks, I knew PG wasn't perfect.
Pneu_DA22.jpg


Well that section is all I've got for now, time to go do some more work, well, more like go have some more fun!

Thanks for looking!

Dave
 
Now here is where having more experience would come in handy. On both occasions, hand and pneumatic sanding, I was able to get Menz PG to finish so well that I had a hard time believing it. But after removing the sanding marks from the first section I could not get those results again. I tried a technique similar to "Pad cleaning on the fly" and re-polishing, then a light spritz of lube to revive the polish and hit it again until it flashed. Then I took the pad inside rinsed it out and tried it all again. No luck, any ideas as to why I can't get those same results? I figure it was clear coat build-up in the pad that was marring the finish. Or I just got impatient...

Well as I posted in another thread, I jumped to 3M Ultrafine on a flat gray pad to remove the marring from PG. It worked wonderfully! By now the driveway probably has full sun for some pics. I'll go do some inspecting and IPA wipeing...
 
Wow it's really impressive what sanding can make, huge difference!
I have orange peel on my hood, but I'm really afraid to wet sand...
Great post.
 
Looks Nice!

Nice photo work capturing the orange peel as well as the areas that you removed it from. :xyxthumbs:
 
Thanks guy's! Believe me, I took A LOT of pics to get the good ones. GLL- is your hood factory paint? I'm pretty timid about even trying to sand factory clear, but I've sanded orange peel out of a few repainted panels on various cars now and pretty comfy with it, and the machine just makes it a breeze. Since it does not rotate, it is SOOO easy to control, I bet the 6" P3000 trizact discs on a similar pneumatic sander would be safe enough but don't take my word as a guarantee. :xyxthumbs:
 
good job, but hard work!
I'd certainly would have run to the store to pick up some paper though.
How many sheets of trizac did you blow through?
 
Oh I haven't finished the whole car. The small hand sanded area I used one piece of 800 cut to fit the soft sanding block then a sheet and a half of the 3000 (5-7 pieces cut to fit the block) to remove the 800 marks. Then I did a larger section (including the hand sanded area) with just one 1500 trizact disc on the Pneumatic palm sander, which doesn't seem to be worn out yet.
 
Thanks guy's! Believe me, I took A LOT of pics to get the good ones. GLL- is your hood factory paint? I'm pretty timid about even trying to sand factory clear, but I've sanded orange peel out of a few repainted panels on various cars now and pretty comfy with it, and the machine just makes it a breeze. Since it does not rotate, it is SOOO easy to control, I bet the 6" P3000 trizact discs on a similar pneumatic sander would be safe enough but don't take my word as a guarantee. :xyxthumbs:

No it's not factory. My hood and front bumper has been replaced/repaint last summer. I didn't have orange peel before that...
 
How much the body shop paid *you* to fix their mess? :-) That kind of orange peel is just not acceptable. Although I do understand your perspective that if something needs to be done right, there is no better person than oneself to do it. I do hope you extracted a major discount from the body shop. A body shop owner or supervisor who lets this one go out the door needs to be expelled from the industry.

- Vikas
 
Very nice!
Read your post last week and it reminded me I needed to do the same to my lexus. I did mine over the weekend. I'll post up a thread once I get the rest of the pics off my camera and I dont want to hijack your thread!

Good work
 
How much the body shop paid *you* to fix their mess? :-) That kind of orange peel is just not acceptable. Although I do understand your perspective that if something needs to be done right, there is no better person than oneself to do it. I do hope you extracted a major discount from the body shop. A body shop owner or supervisor who lets this one go out the door needs to be expelled from the industry.

- Vikas

The paint job was not from a Body Shop, previous owner did it and likely not in a paint booth because there was quite a bit of dust nibs etc., also the color does not match. I did the sanding just as much for the experience as for the look of the car. :xyxthumbs:

Very nice!
Read your post last week and it reminded me I needed to do the same to my lexus. I did mine over the weekend. I'll post up a thread once I get the rest of the pics off my camera and I dont want to hijack your thread!

Good work

Looking forward to your pics! That orange peel was pretty bad too...
 
How much the body shop paid *you* to fix their mess? :-) That kind of orange peel is just not acceptable.

That isn't orange peel, looks more like a moonscape! I'm guessing whoever sprayed it did textured ceilings in their last job. Shoulda stuck with it...

TL
 
Damn Dave maybe I will have to come up there. I have some factory orange peal going on but am SUPER hesitant to touch it...
 
That OP was bad I don't think I've ever seen one that bad. Great job:dblthumb2:
 
Back
Top