I have had the velcro fall off with B&S Pad in short order. I have had the foam on a Lake Country Pad start disintegrating when I was polishing. The Lake Country Pads IMO last quite a long time. The B&S Pad lasted 2 polishings. All that being said about pads whether they be from Lake Country, B&S, Megs, Rupes, etc will eventually wear out from use. I also think that some will last longer than others but ALL will eventually fail or need to be replaced.
That is why I have a bunch of all colors. I prefer the Lake Country Pads (any of them) as I have had the best experience with them. Others may have a difference of opinion.