Review: Blackfire Trim and Tire Sealant

Desertnate

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 5, 2013
Messages
6,190
Reaction score
236
A couple of months ago, I was fortunate to be selected in a drawing here to receive a couple of products and provide a review. Life kept me from doing reviews of both products as quickly as I would have liked, but here is the second instalment. Again, thank you Nick for selecting me back then. Testing out these products has been a lot of fun.

This instalment is a review of Blackfire's Trim and Tire Sealant. While a long time in coming, this test was timely. I just finished doing the winter prep on my families cars and I know have the opportunity to see how this product holds up through the winter.

watermark.php


I've never used a trim sealant before, so I wasn't sure exactly what to expect going into this review as it turned out to be very different from the protectants I've used in the past.

The container, as you can tell from the picture, is typical Blackfire fare...durable black plastic bottles you don't have to worry about dropping. This is the four ounce bottle, but it is also available in eight.

The directions state you should use a MF pad. I used a MF pad when applying it on one vehicle and a MF towel on the second. Both methods worked well. I actually like using a towel since I'm able to get it into tight areas easier than a pad.

The directions also state putting a nickle sized drop on a pad and then rub it into the desired area. From my experience, that is WAY too much product unless you're hitting the cladding on an 80's vintage Pontiac, Chevy Avalanche, or Volvo XC70. I think I might have used a two nickle sized drop on the entire first car! A little goes a long way.

First victim: A 2014 VW. The product was applied to all plastic and rubber surfaces.

Cladding around the exhaust
watermark.php


50/50 on rear wiper arm:
watermark.php


50/50 on rubber window trim:
watermark.php


VW Logo on trunk.
watermark.php


Second victim: 2013 Toyota Highlander that sees A LOT of miles.

50/50 on mirror mount:
watermark.php


Mirror Mount finished:
watermark.php


Mirror Mount, opposite side:
watermark.php


Observations
- The product goes a LONG way. It spreads very thin.

- The thinner you apply the product, the more even the appearance when buffing it out. If you want darker results, apply thin layers, vs slapping on a thick coat.

- The product will seal the pad/towel after it saturates a bit. That's good since the product doesn't soak in much, but it also makes it run off the applicator easier.

- Not all plastics are the same. All of the plastics on the VW and all rubber trim absorbed the product and good looking results were easy. However, the smooth plastic around the mirrors on the Toyota didn't spread as nice and didn't absorb the product as quickly. It was odd. I had to really work at getting it to look nice. Everywhere else was fine.

- Once buffed off, the finish varies between a dark satin to OEM flat black. The more product you use, the more satin-like finish you see.

- The product dries very quickly, so no worries about smearing or running when it encounters rain. The finish is dry to the touch; nothing slick, sticky, or oily.

- When applying you might see marks from application, but they go away when buffing, leaving a nice smooth finish.

-I didn't use it on my tires. Call me cheap, but I have a hard time using a product that's $20 for 4oz on tires!

- I only used .5 ~ 1 oz at most to do both cars!

Verdict

I like the product. It was refreshing change from the protectants I've used in the past. I'm looking forward to seeing how it holds up. The VW saw rain this week, and the trim was beading just like the waxed surfaces of the car. Even better, the product didn't run onto the paint when it got wet!

The Trim Sealant made me reconsider my product choices. In the past, I shied away from trim sealants because of their price. I stuck with less permanent protectants...but then I grumbled when they faded after a couple weeks and/or ran all over the paint as they fail. If this product comes even close to living up to it's claims, I'll be a convert. Long, lasting, dry touch trim sealants may be expensive, but their longevity and protection over time seem to be worth it.

I'm glad I got to try this product out courtesy of Nick and AG. I look forward to working my way to the bottom of the bottle.
 
I used this on my VW CC 2 months ago. The car sits outside 24/7 and it is still holding up no problem, and looks great.

Is that a CC by chance you were putting that on? Rear valence looks familiar.
 
Nice review. Looks like a product I'll be putting on my list.
 
Very nice review, interested to here about the longevity, especially on that VW. My wife has a Tiguan and they've got a decent amount of that black plastic and I'm looking for the best costing for it.

Anyone able to compare longevity to CarPro DLux?
 
I agree with many of your sentiments about the product. I also like it, but I wouldn't say I love it.
 
Great review, Also one of the winners still procrastinating on my review did one part of one the cars I wanted to do with pics but need set aside time to write review. thats what winter is for 5 months coming up with no fishing makes a lot boring sunday's.
 
Thanks everyone for the kind words. Hopefully everyone found the review useful.

I used this on my VW CC 2 months ago. The car sits outside 24/7 and it is still holding up no problem, and looks great.

Is that a CC by chance you were putting that on? Rear valence looks familiar.

It's a GTI. Interesting how two totally different cars would have such similar parts.

I agree with many of your sentiments about the product. I also like it, but I wouldn't say I love it.

I'm in the same position, but only because I don't experience with a product in this category to compare. I may try others, but at least I know this one works, so I'll have someplace to turn if others don't live up to my expectation.
 
This class of products (UTTG, WETS, and this Blackfire product) is really fantastic! When you add the coatings (DLux, C4, etc) it's really possible to keep your trim looking great forever as opposed to the bad old days when if you didn't keep on it (which was virtually impossible) it would always fade.
 
This class of products (UTTG, WETS, and this Blackfire product) is really fantastic! When you add the coatings (DLux, C4, etc) it's really possible to keep your trim looking great forever as opposed to the bad old days when if you didn't keep on it (which was virtually impossible) it would always fade.

That's what I quickly realized with this product. I've used different protectants on both cars, but as can be seen in the pictures both the rubber and plastic bits were fading fast. The VW is only a year old and the Toyota a little over two.

I'm really curious how this product stacks up against the Wolfgang Exterior Trim Sealant. They are the same price per volume and seems to be the same type of product. I can't imagine PBMG selling the same product under two different names.

If the good people of AG would like for me to do a comparison between the two, I have one more family car to use as a testbed! :)
 
WANT TO ASK....WHATS THE BEST WAY TO PREPARE AND CLEAN ALL weather seals and rubber thoroughly on your car vehicle BEFORE I USE 1Z Einszett Rubber Care Stick Gummi Pflege, I WANT TO DO MY MOON ROOF MOLDING OUTSIDE AND INSIDE AND WEATHER STRIPPING AND WHAT DO I CLEAN THEM WITH FIRST BEFORE I APPLY 1Z Einszett Rubber Care Stick Gummi Pflege, AND ALSO ANY RECOMENDATIONS IF THERE IS ANY OTHER PRODUCT I SHOULD USE BESIDES 1Z Einszett Rubber Care Stick Gummi Pflege AFTER I CLEAN ALL THE RUBBER WEATHER STRIPPING AND THE OUTSIDE WEATHER STRIP FOR THE MOONROOF TY
 
WANT TO ASK....WHATS THE BEST WAY TO PREPARE AND CLEAN ALL weather seals and rubber thoroughly on your car vehicle BEFORE I USE 1Z Einszett Rubber Care Stick Gummi Pflege, I WANT TO DO MY MOON ROOF MOLDING OUTSIDE AND INSIDE AND WEATHER STRIPPING AND WHAT DO I CLEAN THEM WITH FIRST BEFORE I APPLY 1Z Einszett Rubber Care Stick Gummi Pflege, AND ALSO ANY RECOMENDATIONS IF THERE IS ANY OTHER PRODUCT I SHOULD USE BESIDES 1Z Einszett Rubber Care Stick Gummi Pflege AFTER I CLEAN ALL THE RUBBER WEATHER STRIPPING AND THE OUTSIDE WEATHER STRIP FOR THE MOONROOF TY

I haven't used Gummi Pfledge in over 10 years, but from my experience it is not a product you want to use on the outside of the car. I used it on the interior weather seals of my BMW to keep them from getting dried out and making odd creaking noises while driving. From what I remember it did not leave a dry surface when applied and it was a little oily. It was a great product for conditioning weather seals, not something I'd want to use on exterior rubber and plastic for long term protection. In fact, I don't think it would work well on hard plastic at all.

The best way to prep the surfaces is to scrub them down good with APC to ensure all the soap, old protectants, spray wax, etc is gone. The cleaner the surface the better the product will adhere to the surface.

After what I've seen using this product, trim sealants are really the way to go. Protectants are too short lived and the constant re-application is time that can be better spent on something else.
 
I just wanted to provide a quick update on this product and an apology for the horrible grammar and spelling in my original post. Looking at it after two months the mistakes really stand out!

On to the important stuff....

After two months, two snow storms, lots of rain, three hand washings and a trip through a touchless wash, the product is holding up well on both vehicles. The color of some rubber trim around the windows is a little lighter, but it still looks good and beads water really well. Freezing rain on Sunday left lots of perfectly formed ice pearls all over the plastic and rubber trim.
 
This will be my final update to this review.

I got a good look at my car in a semi-clean state in full sun yesterday. While the protectant still appears to be going strong on the plastic bits like the trim around the side mirrors and the area under the wipers, it's failing on the rubber trim around the windows. The rubber trim now has a tortoise-shell appearance caused by water drying and degrading the coating.

My check last night was exactly four months to the day from when it was applied (I didn't plan it that way). Overall, I'm pretty happy with that. I would much rather treat the trim three times a year with this Blackfire product than every other week with a product that ends up running all over the paint. I really wish it would have lasted until I do my spring detail in another month or two.
 
Back
Top