DP Polish and Seal VS McKee’s37 360 mini test.

DMiglio

New member
Joined
Aug 22, 2016
Messages
708
Reaction score
0
Today I was able to get a quick detail in on my wife’s car and thought I’d do a test between these two products. One is a well known AIO from a brand no longer associate with the PBMG family, but has a few recent topics dedicated to it, so I wanted to compare it alongside the new DP AIO product. This DP AIO is new to the market as the brand is only some 3 months old and is still gaining traction here. I’ve used a handful of the DP products and can say they’re all very good, easy to use and offer an enjoyable experience. Now onto the details of this detail ;)

I used one specific and dedicated pad(BOSS perfecting pad) and towel for the application and removal of each product. I worked in about 3x3 sections with 2 each up/down and side/side motions and quick arm speed with little pressure. Both products were shaken for about 30 seconds before use and about 5 seconds before every section was done to keep all ingredients thoroughly mixed.

I was intending to do a gloss enhancement as it’s been about a year since it was last polished so had some light water spotting and grime on/in the clear. I had no plans to remove swirls or scratches so the pictures won’t show any type of correction. I allowed the polishes to sit for about 15 minutes on the hood while I did other areas of the car. Driver Side received 360 and the Passenger Side, DP AIO.

aad36c13a1d321227703b68d8c471a14.jpg

fc28836d930059cc13f0f4792a8a4dd4.jpg


Here’s DP AIO with its own towel and own pad(forgot to take pic of fresh pad, I had done one section already). The product has a strong pleasant cherry smell, it’s quite thick and is a vibrant pink color. It was extremely easy to work with and after a few passes it had thinned out and spread over the section with ease.

94a433b2614cdaeab643931860c57434.jpg

cdfe301673de8d0d08eec12b9ca88ccb.jpg


Here is the M37 360 polish, with its own towel and pad. As you can see I used about 4 quarter sized drops for each section with each product to try and keep them as controlled and consistent at possible. The product looks almost exactly the same as the DP AIO, but that’s where the similarities end. 360 has a slight cherry smell(ok the similarities end here) with a pronounced solvent smell, is much thinner in consistency and seems just a bit harder to work with, but still very easy. It too spreads over the panel and gives good working time, but does start to go clear the more you work.

Here’s the hood all set up with polishes applied and allowed to sit(this is only about 5 minutes after). You can see in the pics how much deeper the pink of the DP product is and how the 360 is much more of a pale pink color.

bfde84334f9e1693dcc4d06e3d8129f8.jpg

2cc56f8866b827cef09fd3a1f9314aef.jpg



After letting them sit for about 15 minutes to haze up and bond, I wiped the polishes off. The DP AIO wipes so easily I had to check to make sure I was actually wiping something off the surface! It was immediately like staring at a fresh panel, clean, no streaks or smears. Turned towel over and buffed off any remaining polish. I did the same procedure to the 360 side and it too wiped off very nicely but did have a bit of dusting at wipe off, nothing terrible but something to note. The DP AIO definitely wins out here as the wipe off couldn’t be easier or cleaner! I probably could’ve dragged the towel on the hood and had the polish removed that way haha. As far as enhancing and cleaning up the paint, they both performed very well, light spotting gone and grime removed!

b9c2f2bf09baeabe845f39365eb6310a.jpg


This process was done to the rest of the car, split down 50/50 DP on Passenger Side and 360 on Driver Side. The test will only be for the hood as I used a tip shared and learned from CruzsCarWash(AG name), and that is to apply the AIO and then wipe with a spray sealant after its sat on the panels as you finish the car. I used Megs Ultimate Fast Finish as it’s a pretty resilient spray sealant for how easy it is to work with. This will be part of a different test to see how durable this combo is(AIO+spray sealant) since recent tests here have shown some very mixed results with just an AIO, yet many of us here love using them over maybe a medium/finishing polish as they tend to be easier to work with and more sun friendly(just generalization!).

Anyways we are expecting rain in the next few days as Illinois seems to be having a bit of a monsoon season right now but today and tomorrow should remain dry. I will report with beading shots as soon as possible and the first wash(a week or two from now) will hopefully be at a pay and spray and I’ll use an LSP friendly shampoo. If I can’t do that I’ll do a simple rinseless or waterless wash and try to capture how the AIO’s respond.

Thanks for reading, your reward, a few finished shots just to add some eye candy to the overall post!

a04ee1022ad53c8d2468a3df00883a54.jpg


40420c97d3e9fa87cd904b8846b69d9f.jpg


2ed3a535f21c79af7085ee51aac2c34c.jpg


15c96dc7ac2e1cbd67130bfc52b54cbf.jpg


846b4d947976f66776d6c1857e6c4ab8.jpg
 
Thanks Paul, hoping the hood with no added sealant just AIO lasts longer than a few weeks, but after Friday we’re expecting storms for 5 days straight!
 
Thanks Paul, hoping the hood with no added sealant just AIO lasts longer than a few weeks, but after Friday we’re expecting storms for 5 days straight!

How are you at ark building? ;)
 
Haha well if I’m honest, not very good, I’ll just have to find anything that floats!

I could empty out all of my product bottles, and when strung together, might just be enough to float a small town in Rhode Island. ;)
 
Thanks Paul, hoping the hood with no added sealant just AIO lasts longer than a few weeks, but after Friday we’re expecting storms for 5 days straight!

Looks sweet, very nice "flop" to that paint too. :coolgleam:

re: storms. We've had 3 days straight of rain, with more forecast for the next 5 days as well. Tornado warnings/spottings the other night, and they had to put up the floodwalls in parts of the city. Poor Michigan has it even worse as several dams have failed.
 
I could empty out all of my product bottles, and when strung together, might just be enough to float a small town in Rhode Island. ;)

Hahah might take you up on that offer, I’ll empty mine as well and build that ark!
 
Looks sweet, very nice "flop" to that paint too. :coolgleam:

re: storms. We've had 3 days straight of rain, with more forecast for the next 5 days as well. Tornado warnings/spottings the other night, and they had to put up the floodwalls in parts of the city. Poor Michigan has it even worse as several dams have failed.

Thanks Rambler! It’s a nice color, wouldn’t say it’s a favorite of mine but it’s quite unique in that it has a silver-bronze-brown tone to it that’s looks great all shined up! Loses its appeal though when it’s a bit cloudy out sadly as the metallic goes “flat.”

I hadn’t heard that about the dams, the storms lately in the Midwest have been quite intense so I’m not surprised by them causing major damage. There’s a town near me, Wheaton IL, that’s largely flood plains and I’ve seen pictures of houses completely surrounded by water, streets flooded, backyards that look like ponds. It’s been nice having no rain for a chance but looks like they’ll be here soon for about a week straight.
 
Very nice review!! Sounds super easy to work with and I like that. Looking forward to updates.
 
Very nice review!! Sounds super easy to work with and I like that. Looking forward to updates.

It’s extremely easy to use, this is the 4th time I’ve used it and the experience reminds me s lot of HD/3D Speed. Much like Speed, it’s a bit tough to get out of pads though and will stain them.
 
Subbed! I'm enjoying these AIO tests. You get to the end of the test quicker than these coating tests haha. Fast finish seems like a great product to throw on top, I'm curious to see how it fairs.
 
Hey DetailZeus, sorry I never replied idk how I missed it!! But yeah I kind of like them for the same reason, they’re relatively short term tests and being so easy to use doesn’t hurt if they fail after 3 months. You pull out the polisher, a few pads and AIO and good to go! I’m trying to do my best and not use any toppers on the hood and any gloss enhancing/wax shampoos to really test the AIO and not any toppers.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Update from 5/24, just a few days late haha.

My wife and I work early mornings, we had a couple hours of showers from about 4am-6am. I took her around 5:15 and it’s about 5 miles round trip(she works so close I’m jealous!). When I left for work it was 6:30 so the car had a taken a short drive and then parked about an hour before I took these pics. I applied the AIOs only about a week before these pics and needless to say, they’re still there!

This is an overall hood pic followed by the same pic zoomed in with a line drawn down the middle to show an approximate split between the two AIOs.

Left: DP AIO Polish and Seal Right:McKee’s37 360
438c9f71efde352da7e943c04cc2b778.jpg


95110e8606b447496e3d0b2d10d2e88c.jpg


Here’s a half hood shot of the DP AIO followed by a zoomed shot for more detailed beading.

fe43b12fdd258e20e888cdafe33ea91a.jpg



8edcd7c5b5f5afc39a8c31c0e2876e28.jpg



This is the McKee’s37 360 side and zoomed in pic of the beads.

474d86f61b1083811d2a4e584eec0352.jpg


572991e4523c540558ddc700584b6907.jpg




So there we have it, after about a week McKee’s37 360 has the edge over DP AIO. The car sits outside 24/7 and has been covered in pollen since the second I wiped the AIOs off the paint. Semi frequent showers and a few heavy rain storms in that time as well. I hope to get more pics in before next week but if not I plan to get to a pay and spray and test the water behavior of the hood as well as the rest of the car with Megs UFF. I wasn’t thinking when I took these pics, I def should’ve grabbed some beading shots of the overall car that morning to give a visual of the AIOs on the hood and the UFF sections. The beading of the UFF sections did look quite a bit nicer and tighter than the 360 section of the hood and looked strong.


Let me know if there’s anything specific you’d like me to test or if I’m missing anything so far!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
UPDATE: 15 days later and I gave the car it’s first wash, it’s outside 24/7 been getting a lot of pollen accumulation and on and off rains. The first 7 days or so saw heavy storms and downpours, along with good beading and sheeting. The past 7 or so days, I assume due to all the pollen and road grime from rain drives, hasn’t seen the same beading or sheeting. I waited about 2 weeks as I believe this is what Eldorado2k asked/wanted to see, that time was up and I wanted to get this into the pay and spray and give it a wash!

Before I left I took some hood shots.

I tried to capture the dirt and grime build up but the metallic is popping through with the sunlight.

34e2c8d12b3dd731be44024bc3da846d.jpg


4e954c38123408ff2ea79eabdd23a12c.jpg


48cf7acfb19dd9cc29fc38c1d143164b.jpg


c6faa33614a5d0ca350ae8e1dd988fc7.jpg



If you remember, the rest of the car, besides being split 50/50 with 360 on the drivers side and DP AIO on the passenger side, I applied Megs UFF over the entire car besides the hood. I have pictures of the water behavior from the AIO products and UFF.

The following are pictures of UFF taken within a couple seconds after being sprayed down, I haven’t taken a mitt to the paint work yet. I wanted to test the surface tension of the sealant when it’s been covered in pollen and grime.

Roof

100e8831cd053bb40a2da95f7cc561df.jpg


Passenger side door(this side has DP AIO, very similar behavior on driver side with 360).

e8f386c326e82fe31c5f9f8a5a62b159.jpg


Those panels have UFF on them, this is the hood with a thorough rinse wearing only the AIO’s. DP AIO on passenger side, 360 on driver side.

c9c547ecfc3373896391532814fc7b42.jpg


25515661d2bc7d4661a46fa7d13be266.jpg


Pretty darn flat, they cleared water quite slowly and 360 was fairing a little bit better. I then washed it with DP Car Wash(I’m moving and most of my stuff is packed up now, I wanted to use Reset but it’s already in Florida). I have pictures of the soap on the surface to show how the sealants seems reacting to it.

17824127618e45b7a109383178251da5.jpg


8d10ed7395982b41e0517a9a032af75d.jpg


DP AIO is looking pretty flat, 360 is resisting it a bit and I may have washed that area down 10 seconds before the DP AIO side. I then did a final rinse of the vehicle, immediately after spraying the panel is FLAT, I continue to rinse and the panel starts to come back a bit. The pics will show the change.

First rinse picture taken immediately after

1c977409e487379a212ec04821cc1a8f.jpg


Then I rinsed a bit more “thoroughly” and took pictures right after, maybe 10 seconds after and then a minute after to see the sheeting(they were done beading by this point).

cabce12f163c3f6695cc704d6bc6544e.jpg


1d84f6d6efde54187c2a872af39ea3f1.jpg


ce0d7a5f42cdb001cb772371831efc74.jpg


4634bd4b6306a1807a6c44cf3f9fc695.jpg


The 360 was performing quite well in the sheeting department, if I had a flooding hose I’m sure it would have no problems clearing water. The DP AIO struggled quite a bit here, I think it could still be flooded to sheet water better, but I doubt it would be impressive. 360 other than only lightly beading, still resisted the pollen/grime from the first rinse, then resisted the soap during the wash and cleared the water at 2-3x the pace of the DP AIO. I’d say there’s a clear winner here and although DP AIO might have another 2 weeks in it I decided it wasn’t worth it as I’m moving in 2 weeks. 360 did well here and could probably go another 4-6 weeks. So looks like DP AIO would make about a month and 360 2 months.

For sh#ts and giggles, here’s a few panels with UFF after the wash and pictures taken within 3-5 seconds of spraying the panels down.

Roof, 360 in foreground, DP AIO in background.

84861c908340c215129cc7514b126024.jpg


767faa8ff6007824bdce744ecf6d995e.jpg


DP AIO on passenger side, drivers side looked about the same.

6dc249a4397a0821f42cba022229fbc3.jpg


5c40dad8ad9bd70315d9c40ec6d43029.jpg



There it is, finished test. I feel an AIO still has its place, especially in outdoor work, high heat and humidity. They seem to work in much more varying conditions and can be manipulated with pad choice. Also, you can take a durable sealant and throw it on top it and it seems to bond and hold up well short term. Using something like UFF only added some 15 minutes to the total detail, added much more protection and applied while I wiped off the AIO’s which I had to do anyways!! This is a great combo and a bit of a game changer for overall speed, quality and mobile work as well.

Some finished shots after using Turtle Wax Ceramic Spray Wax and a final wipe with Megs Last Touch Detailer.

ba2e4597730273992f45f563006c4d3f.jpg


cd1bdde10c62410eadd43bb0e916dc22.jpg


36efe2ed9d7cf9c973b6b4bb6228c143.jpg



Tell me your thoughts on the test, do you feel any different about AIO’s because of it? Would you use them without an added topper and just reapply every month or 2 or add a durable sealant and stretch it out another 2-4 months? I’m interested it what people have to say, so if you have any tests or ideas on AIO’s, please share!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Hey Paul, thanks so much! It was a lot of work and I wanted to be as in-depth and honest as possible.
 
Nice, thanks for the updates.

Good luck on the move (one of those terrible experiences in life IMO). You moving for work? Weather? Family?
 
Back
Top