As long as the defect is topical you should be able to remove it.
- Did you do a Test Spot?
- Or buff out the entire hood?
If you did a test spot, did you use a tape line to check the differences between before and after?
Can't stress enough how much this can help trouble shoot problems should they arrive.
If you're finger oils are filling in the marring that means the marring is very light.
Almost everyone here is always focused on perfection all the time, nothing wrong with that but when you get to the point where you don't want to invest more and more and more time into a car that is as was neglected, will probably neglected into the future, (how did it get neglected in the first place? Sitting outside? Washed and waxed often), then maybe get it to where it's good, get it to where it's better and then apply your favorite wax or paint sealant.
If finger oils are making it look better just think what a coat of wax will do.
How does it look in normal light?
Remember, it's hard to please the Cruel Master...
LOL
:xyxthumbs: