The one in the left isn't sold at AG, but look on the smooth plastic above the volume rocker. It's pretty streaky. Silk shine is completely uniform, very easy to use and lasts quite a while.
Chemical Guys Silk Shine. I had it on my Civic's dash for 18 months and it never faded. Makes everything a dark matte black. Also, no streaking at all even over smooth plastics.
It depends on what you're looking for. I went from a Honda to an Audi. My Audi does a lot of things better, but there were somethings that I preferred with my Honda.
3 weeks later with no cleaning at all and they still look good as expected. On my front left tire, it came off just in the one spot pictured, but everywhere else is still good. Whenever I get around to washing my car, I'll add one coat to that one tire.
I put up these signs, make sure they write "Do Not Wash" on the RO, and I take one walk around video of the car when I drop it off at the dealer getting close enough to the car that if damage was there it would be able to be seen in the video.
I don't currently use it only because I have so much traditional tire dressing left that I want to get rid of. I would definitely use it again in the future though.