The bottle looks like the bottle on the left and the packaging matched your pictures.
I used the applicator block with the “suede” pieces that are part of the kit. In the box you showed there were 3 or 4 of the suede cloths and an instruction page.
I used several different types of towels to buff it off, some thinner and some thicker, all with the same fuzz appearing.
For flash time, I tried just about everything I could. I let it set for 1 minute and went all the way up to maybe 15 minutes. The longer I let it sit the “stickier” it was but it would always buff off and always made the fuzz. Some times I would get it looking pretty good but there would be some fuzz and as I tried to pick up that fuzz, more and more fuzz would show up. I know the picture isn’t great above but that fuzz was bright white and none of my towels are white or have ever been washed with anything white. The same type of towels, washed together with the others, did not have any fuzz when I used them with Reload.
Thanks for digging in and trying to diagnose the problem.