I opened my first bottle of this stuff and I was expecting a lotion like consistency. Instead, it looks almost like oil and water. Ive shaken the hell out of it but it doesn't come out with a lotion like feel. It comes out more like water with yellow stuff that's separated from the liquid. Is this normal? If not, do I send it back, ask for a refund, etc? I still used it but it just didn't feel right coming out of the bottle in it's currently liquid form.