I posted awhile back about decided between the 3401 and the pe14 150. I ended up going with the 3401, just received it in the mail today.
I work on two and a half cars today, thought I would quickly share my first impressions.
I have been using the Makita, and before this I used the Dewalt quite a bit. I've also used the Porter Cable random orbit.
First things first, the 3401 is very light compared to the rotary polishers. You can also sense the build quality when you pick it up.
I found the handle that comes with it isn't great, I took it off after the first hour or so. To stick with the positives first, the 3401 works extremely well. With only a few passed with product I'm very familiar with I was getting much faster and clearer results. I think the smaller 6" pads allow a bit more control than the standard 7-8" pads, and the movement of the 3401 insures you aren't leaving buffer trails. The weight also makes it more manageable which in turn produces better results I think.
When it comes to the controls and ergonomics I was less impressed. You can't see what speed setting you're at without turning the machine over, I've found this to be really annoying. Maybe it will be less of an issue once I recognize the sounds of the machine better. I can't seem to find a comfortable way to hold it either, with or without the handle. Compared to the Makita, the vibration is VERY strong. I'm used to a heavy machine, but I felt like the 3401 was trying to wiggle its way out of my hands from time to time. I remember this with my Porter Cable as well, but as the 3401 has more power, it feels a bit worse. So I can't say it was an enjoyable machine to use, but the results were definitely superior. This is only day one, so I will check back again at the end of the week. I'm looking to replace my personal polisher at home as well, I think I may end up with the pe14 150 for personal use. If I find any interesting cars to do, I will post photos as well.
I work on two and a half cars today, thought I would quickly share my first impressions.
I have been using the Makita, and before this I used the Dewalt quite a bit. I've also used the Porter Cable random orbit.
First things first, the 3401 is very light compared to the rotary polishers. You can also sense the build quality when you pick it up.
I found the handle that comes with it isn't great, I took it off after the first hour or so. To stick with the positives first, the 3401 works extremely well. With only a few passed with product I'm very familiar with I was getting much faster and clearer results. I think the smaller 6" pads allow a bit more control than the standard 7-8" pads, and the movement of the 3401 insures you aren't leaving buffer trails. The weight also makes it more manageable which in turn produces better results I think.
When it comes to the controls and ergonomics I was less impressed. You can't see what speed setting you're at without turning the machine over, I've found this to be really annoying. Maybe it will be less of an issue once I recognize the sounds of the machine better. I can't seem to find a comfortable way to hold it either, with or without the handle. Compared to the Makita, the vibration is VERY strong. I'm used to a heavy machine, but I felt like the 3401 was trying to wiggle its way out of my hands from time to time. I remember this with my Porter Cable as well, but as the 3401 has more power, it feels a bit worse. So I can't say it was an enjoyable machine to use, but the results were definitely superior. This is only day one, so I will check back again at the end of the week. I'm looking to replace my personal polisher at home as well, I think I may end up with the pe14 150 for personal use. If I find any interesting cars to do, I will post photos as well.