Really sad to see this thread title and then see it was started by you Shane .... I cant seem to find the right emoticon for 'someone deserves to be flogged for this'.
That really sucks. I remember when I first got my TSX, a week later someone backed right into me. Brought it to the body shop and had it fixed but it never the same.
I would take the check and buy something cool here. :dblthumb2:
you should be able to find the parts in good shape at some local pick-it lots. Save some $$ and get the parts and install. Then have a professional repaint as needed.