For me, it all depends on the surfaces in the car. In my wife's 2015 Expedition it really doesn't matter what I use...the dash and door panels are a hard black plastic and they respond well to any type of cleaner or dressing. I usually use Mothers VLR or CG inner clean in her car. I rather the smell of VLR, but they both fade fast. I also have a bottle of the Sonax stuff too, and I like that one as well. Those 3 leave the plastics looking clean but not shiny. Now in my 2016 Honda Accord I use Poorboy's natural look cause for some reason it's the only one that doesn't streak to high hell on the dash. I don't know what kind of rubberized coating Honda puts on that dash but it doesn't like most products I've tried on it for some reason. The natural look does add some shine but after a couple of min I come back with a mf towel and knock it down. It also smells great.