I've applied AG product to part of my car and I've applied non-AG product to a different part of the car and I want to start a thread about what I observe over time. The non-AG product is not available from any American retailers (at least that I can find, and I looked) so I imported it myself. Would this thread violate the forum rules? I have no stake in any product other than wanting to share experiences.
Moderators - Rules question
- Thread starter bofh
- Start date
acuRAS82
New member
- May 30, 2017
- 2,847
- 0
I personally don’t see a problem with it if you don’t discuss the purchase location or hype it up like it’s soooo awesome. Anything beyond that would seem to provide good info to which half of is related to an AG product vs something else.
Note: I’m not a mod! But I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express a few months ago.
Note: I’m not a mod! But I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express a few months ago.
PaulMys
Active member
- Jan 14, 2014
- 10,772
- 3
Lmao!
- Thread starter
- #5
Someone just mentioned that Autopia has no such product rule. Looking through their FAQ indeed I don't see any mention of product affinity, and I haven't heard back from AG (banker's hours, eh!). I still don't understand the difference between AG and Autopia in terms of online presence but I guess I will post there about this when I do.
BudgetPlan1
Well-known member
- Dec 21, 2015
- 2,139
- 208
Yep, as long as no link to vendor, free to talk about any product on Autopia forums.
Not so here on Autogeek but since it's their forum, it's their rules...no harm, no foul.
This is true. When the conversation is about the Harbor Freight DA polisher, we’re told to go to the “HF car forum.” But when something is said about it being a poor polisher, well, we can post about that all day long.
Sent from my iPhone using Autogeekonline mobile app
PaulMys
Active member
- Jan 14, 2014
- 10,772
- 3
The rules are the rules, but..... If you are actually trying to be helpful with a comparison/review, I would see no problem. But again, "Technically"...........
The problems only seem to arise when certain members feel the need to attack every single post/product/opinion that does not agree with their personal opinions, and cannot stand to just leave well enough alone.
The problems only seem to arise when certain members feel the need to attack every single post/product/opinion that does not agree with their personal opinions, and cannot stand to just leave well enough alone.
Calendyr
New member
- Jun 9, 2013
- 3,996
- 0
My stance on these rules, and based on experience in the past 8 years is that the Mods are not gonna panic if you mention something that is not sold by Autogeek unless you promote other stores and such. We are all here to talk about detailing, processes and products. Sometimes the best product for doing something is not offered yet by Autogeek. I think as long as you are respectful, it will not be a problem.
Often when someone mentions a product not sold here, the members will give better alternatives available here.
Often when someone mentions a product not sold here, the members will give better alternatives available here.
Desertnate
Well-known member
- Aug 5, 2013
- 6,236
- 291
I've also seen pro's here post their work and some of the products mentioned in the documentation of the work is not sold here, and when it's non-US members, is not sold in the US at all. Those seem to go pretty well.
On a related question, do we even have "moderators" here? Mike occasionally takes on the role, and I've seen "Admin" and Meghan pop in occasionally, but neither of them have ever done any moderation that I've seen. The nice thing is it isn't often needed around here. The down side is this type of situation arises and no one knows who to ask.
On a related question, do we even have "moderators" here? Mike occasionally takes on the role, and I've seen "Admin" and Meghan pop in occasionally, but neither of them have ever done any moderation that I've seen. The nice thing is it isn't often needed around here. The down side is this type of situation arises and no one knows who to ask.
- Thread starter
- #13
OP here. To be more specific, I bought Nova Lustre and Jet and applied them to one panel of my wife's daily driver. To the adjacent panel I applied Sonax PNS, Wax, and BSD. My plan is to let them be there for 6-12 months and just see what happens. Nova products aren't retailed by anyone in the US so I don't feel like I'm being disrespectful to AG's business. Autopia would work, I guess; maybe there's a better forum I don't know about?
WristyManchego
New member
- Sep 8, 2018
- 282
- 0
Detailing world, no product rules there but UK centric.
Nova isn’t the brand, Concours is.
Nova isn’t the brand, Concours is.
Mike Phillips
Active member
- Dec 5, 2022
- 51,004
- 7
In my opinion and experience, a GOOD Moderator is like a Police Officer. They are here to protect and serve the community by monitoring the discussion and when needed - enforcing the rules.
Car Wax History
When I came to Autogeek in 2009 there were no forum rules there was a general statement that basically asked everyone to be nice. At that time we had a couple of troublemakers on the forum that acted like bullies. After about a year, the forum rules I wrote for MeguiarsOnline were tweaked here and there to make them more appropriate for Autogeek.com and then incorporated to this forum.
Forum rules are like boundaries. They show people what is acceptable and what is not acceptable behavior. With a set of real forum rules, you give the Moderators something to enforce. Then when someone breaks the forum rules, or in most cases, continually breaks forum rules, "we" that is Autogeek NEVER bans anyone from this forum. A person bans themselves by continually breaking the forum rules.
I've never claimed to be a good Moderator as it interferes with what I enjoy doing and that's the education side of this forum. Playing the Bad Cop by enforcing rules for those that cannot abide by them is easy to do but it's better left to someone else to handle.
Just to note - when a person joins this forum, part of the registration form includes a "check box" at the bottom of the online form that states by checking the box you agree to follow the forum rules. Of course - most people don't read fine print for anything now days.
And something I think people simply don't see is the link to the forum rules at the top of EVERY page on this forum. So there's really no excuse for not knowing the rules, all a person has to do is look, click and read.
That is the nice thing about this forum. It's helpful AND friendly.
I agree. I'd like to see an official moderator assigned to this duty. The BEST Moderator I've even known was my old friend Tim aka 2hodford. He was the lead Moderator on the MOL forum when I ran it. I would take the time to read through a "problem" post or thread and then apply the forum rules fairly.
