Pinnacle or XMT Clay?

[mwoolfso]

I have not had any problems with the Mothers clay falling apart and degrading fast.

Would love to know how clay can degrade. It can get dirty over time, sure.

 

[jeremy0203]

since it all comes from the same company id bet its pretty safe to assume that its all the same, only difference being in how aggressive it is.

 

[SR99]

Order of aggressiveness:

From this thread (1= more aggressive)
1. Pinnacle XMT speed clay
2. Mothers (gold)
3. Pinnacle ultra poly

and from this post on another forum (with a lot of background info as well): Detailers Automotive Clay: - An Article by Jon Miller - Autopia Forums - Auto Detailing & Car Care Discussion Forum

Aggressiveness (on a scale of 1 to 5)
1 Clay Magic® - Red- very aggressive; most surface marring - 5/5
2 Top of the line purple- slightly less aggressive - 4/5
3 Clay Magic® -Blue- less aggressive; less marring - 3/5
4 Mother's - Yellow- 2/5
5 Sonus Ultra Fine -Green- 1/5

Anyone know where the Pinncale ultra and the XMT speed clay fit in the list of 5?

 

[sproketser]

Order of aggressiveness:

From this thread (1= more aggressive)
1. Pinnacle XMT speed clay
2. Mothers (gold)
3. Pinnacle ultra poly

and from this post on another forum (with a lot of background info as well): Detailers Automotive Clay: - An Article by Jon Miller - Autopia Forums - Auto Detailing & Car Care Discussion Forum

Aggressiveness (on a scale of 1 to 5)
1 Clay Magic® - Red- very aggressive; most surface marring - 5/5
2 Top of the line purple- slightly less aggressive - 4/5
3 Clay Magic® -Blue- less aggressive; less marring - 3/5
4 Mother's - Yellow- 2/5
5 Sonus Ultra Fine -Green- 1/5

Anyone know where the Pinncale ultra and the XMT speed clay fit in the list of 5?

Thanx for the link .