Renny Doyle Beadmaker Revisited - 2month Standalone Review

Pretty sure BM is orange vanilla flavored Speed Shine.....


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Eldorado2k said:
Here’s a review I’m sure some of you weren’t expecting... But like I’ve always stated, I never had anything against this product at all.. Just a big misunderstanding caused by an over sensitive person who turned something out of nothing... But anyways, here’s a review that’s been 2 months in the making. A review unlike anyone that I’ve seen posted anywhere so far.

For the past 2 months I’ve heard so many people talk about “Beadmaker’s cool, but it’s longevity’s poor” or this and that, but it all seemed to revolve around its lack of longevity.

Now here’s where I feel the need to set the record straight as far as all the naysayers out there chirping about “it’s short lived” or whatever.
Those people talking about short lived need to show some results of what they’re yapping about!
Click to expand...

Eldorado2k said:
Now lets put longevity in proper perspective here...
People who put this products longevity up against unrealistic expectations and wonder why it doesn’t hold up the same way their Colinite does need to apply a bit of common sense.
Click to expand...

Eldorado2k said:
Also, for me personally I judge longevity 1st and foremost on how long a product can protect my paint from contaminants bonding to it. Beading is a distant secondary...
Click to expand...

Eldorado2k said:
I intentionally compared it to HD Speed in my post, there wasn’t anything indirect about it. I stand by my statement that this product blows away HD Speed or any other AIO in terms of longevity. Most AIO’s don’t even bead at the 2 week mark, and in this case HD Speed was only beading maybe 20% at a mere 7 days after I used it on my car.
Click to expand...

You're going to take this personally, and it's not my intent and I've never had beef with you and I enjoy your posts, so I hope you consider that when you respond to what I'm going to say.

If you didn't intend to test the longevity, you sure did a poor job of that in your posts. You then compared apples to oranges a little when it comes to AIOs which are machine applied. First you already did a machine polish before applying this product. There are definite benefits to polishing before applying any LSP. As you know, HD is an AIO that polishes and provides protection. Now I don't live in socal, but I have used several AIOs and the good ones have gotten me through an entire North East summer and then some. So a general statement that they don't last more than a week or 2 is misleading. Then you make the claim that AIOs are a more intensive process, sure agreed. But for many of us so would washing and applying bm every week. You're just spreading it out.

I guess i really have no dog in this fight, but just found the thread to be a little confusing and misleading and honestly a weekly "seal" to also be a little unreasonable for most.
 
Next....
1aaa2e94ab10e947202f35bf32e0be1d.gif


Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
 
Klasse Act said:
Next....

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

if you disagree, you could provide an intelligent well thought out counterpoint. There's at least 6 members in this thread who took issue with the post, or were confused. If you want to help... you could.
 
Nope, just "stayin' in my lane", I've said enough about Beadmaker. P&S should be sending us gallons for the pub this has generated, LOL

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
 
Klasse Act said:
Nope, just "stayin' in my lane", I've said enough about Beadmaker. P&S should be sending us gallons for the pub this has generated, LOL
Click to expand...

I have no doubts that P&S will send you something, but guessing it’ll be a paycheck, not more BM. :work:
 
@Belo. No offense taken.
I don’t think wiping the car down every few days is unreasonable, to me it’s easier than waiting till it’s full on dirty and requires a thorough bucket wash. Applying BeadMaker as a drying aid during those wipedowns adds little to no effort to the process.
 
I don’t understand why so many people confuse this product for a quik detailer...
 
Because of its ease of use, where it fits in the detailing process, relatively low protection, and instant gratification, slickness and gloss.

But most importantly for a quick detailer; difficult to streak, no hazing from layering and can be used as a drying aid.

By definition and usage, it is absolutely in the modern Quick Detailer category.

And yes it can absolutely be used to wipe dust.
 
WristyManchego said:
Because of its ease of use, where it fits in the detailing process, relatively low protection, and instant gratification, slickness and gloss.

But most importantly for a quick detailer; difficult to streak and no hazing from layering.

By definition and usage, it is absolutely in the modern Quick Detailer category.

And yes it can be used to wipe dust.
Click to expand...

Show me where on the directions does it state that it’s safe for wiping dust off.

This is the Renny Doyle Quik Detailer.

09eafdbc83f45d86d56c7ee2c2ce4f09.jpg


Renny Doyle Double Black Paint Gloss Showroom Spray N Shine

And this is Beadmaker.

7f2e6b413dec05401238ab146443a162.jpg


Renny Doyle Double Black Bead Maker Paint Protectant

They both have very specific descriptions.
 
Thanks for pointing that out.

It also doesn’t mention use on interiors but that’s what P&S recommend and how high volume shops are using it; as an inside and out detailer.

I’ve mentioned this many times before, it’s the marketing and product positioning which makes Beadmaker such a hotly discussed product. And it always comes down to two things; its longevity and usage.

I’d you use this product purely based on what the bottle promotes (beads and long lasting protection) then you’ll be dissatisfied (besides you). Use it for what the product is good at and where it naturally fits in the detailing process and you’ll be buying gallons.

Simple.
 
WristyManchego said:
Thanks for pointing that out.

It also doesn’t mention use on interiors but that’s what P&S recommend and how high volume shops are using it; as an inside and out detailer.

I’ve mentioned this many times before, it’s the marketing and product positioning which makes Beadmaker such a hotly discussed product. And it always comes down to two things; its longevity and usage.

I’d you use this product purely based on what the bottle promotes (beads and long lasting protection) then you’ll be dissatisfied (besides you). Use it for what the product is good at and where it naturally fits in the detailing process and you’ll be buying gallons.

Simple.
Click to expand...

Can someone with a black test panel please run this experiment between whichever quality Quik Detailer of your choosing vs. Beadmaker... And I’m not talking about some cute meaningless test where it’s used as a drying aid, I’m talking about using them as an actual Quik Detailer. 50/50 test.

9ded67dff5355e9bd3f8ba8df3ef04e3.jpg


e6191f118fbec68d44f30d0a99a2f42d.jpg


Lets see if Beadmaker can do that without scratching the way I’m all but certain a quik detailer like Megs Last Touch can do. I’d love to see this put to rest already...
 
Eldorado2k said:
Can someone with a black test panel please run this experiment between whichever quality Quik Detailer of your choosing vs. Beadmaker... And I’m not talking about some cute meaningless test where it’s used as a drying aid, I’m talking about using them as an actual Quik Detailer. 50/50 test.

9ded67dff5355e9bd3f8ba8df3ef04e3.jpg


e6191f118fbec68d44f30d0a99a2f42d.jpg


Lets see if Beadmaker can do that without scratching the way I’m all but certain a quik detailer like Megs Last Touch can do. I’d love to see this put to rest already...
Click to expand...
I would try but I don’t have a test panel, and I’m not convinced enough to try it on my wife’s recently corrected black paint. I do hope someone can try this though.
 
so even if it's a "better than the others" quick detailer. I still struggle with comparing it to a product like HD speed. But I think we've beaten that one to death haha.
 
Belo said:
so even if it's a "better than the others" quick detailer. I still struggle with comparing it to a product like HD speed. But I think we've beaten that one to death haha.
Click to expand...

It’s not a quik detailer...
 
Wouldn’t it be crazy if the Renny Doyle Spray & Shine leaves the paint looking better than BeadMaker but no one knew because everyone slept on it. Lol.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top