interesting you do like the rupes more.
I'm sure you seen i'm waiting on a forced rotation machine. it has a 25 foot cord!!
I'm thinking i will like it but i'm not sure. I have large hands and don't mine a little work at all. Its good for you.
I'm not sure I would conclusively say that I
like the Rupes more, they both have their pros and cons.
PRO -
- The Rupes has a higher top speed, and is vastly smoother and quieter, to the point where you can run it without hearing protection. The lack of vibration is also going to be better on your hands long term. In that regard, the more expensive polishers (not just Rupes, but Flex and even ShineMate) reduces fatigue from vibration, compare that to a Milwaukee (which is know to be a noisy and chattery) or other lower end machines, extended pro-level usage will lead to long term nerve damage (ask me how I know this). I also like the Rupes speed control wheel.
- The ShineMate has superior torque, so if you have a lot of cutting to do, this will do it easier. This torque somewhat negates the lower top speed. I also prefer the ShineMate throttle and throttle lock, its smoother and easier to engage the lock.
CON -
- The battery placement on the Rupes. I know its popular to hate on this, and while its not ideal, I wouldn't call it a deal breaker. Frankly, I think the battery is just a convenient excuse for some to write it off. But, yeah, it's "different". I will say though, the Rupes battery is very firm to install and remove. And yes, the asking price is rather rude. Granted, I played into that by buying one. But would I do it again, probably not.
- The ShineMate is quite a vocal machine, especially the ramp up and wind down. At the end of the day, all but the Rupes have the same chatter winding down, so its not a deal breaker either.
There is no such thing as the perfect polisher, corded or cordless. Same applies to cars. The smoothness and overall tool balance/feel is what nudges the Rupes above the ShineMate, it really is at a different level on that front. But that edge is not worth the several hundred dollar price premium over its rival.