I never intended for this thread to turn into a 50/50 comparison between 2 products, but I figured might as well because who doesn’t like to see the difference between 2 products under the same exact conditions.
I did a thorough bucket wash on this Kia Saturday morning, then opened the brand new bottle of McKee’s Graphene Deep Gloss Ceramic Sealant which got applied to the passenger side of the hood.
I allowed the McKee’s to haze up as I grabbed another brand new microfiber applicator and applied the Armor All Extreme Shield Wax [sealant] to the drivers side. The AA Shield is literally wipe on, wipe off and you better do it quick for best results. Hand application is the only possible way to apply this stuff because using a DA would result in too long before you came back and buffed off and by then you’d be screwed.
1 thing I noticed as I was buffing off the Armor All… I was using a brand new Kirkland microfiber since I had just got a new batch in the night before and holy crap I hadn’t felt anything that smooth in forever!

i was blown away at how easy and smooth it felt to wipe it off and my 1st thought was “damn that’s what I’ve been missing out on”?
It’s been so long since I had bought new towels because I was under the impression that my towels were more than adequate, afterall I make sure to keep at least 2 main batches separate. 1 for Paint + 1 batch for General Purpose/Interior towels. But seeing the difference in how that new towel felt compared to the ones I’ve been using for paint for who knows how long, hit me like a ton of bricks.
So we’ve got:
McKee’s Graphene [passenger side]
Armor All Shield [drivers side]
Both applied by hand using 2 separate brand new microfiber applicators. 2 separate brand new Kirkland microfiber towels for removal.
I allowed the McKee’s to haze for about 40min. before wiping off. The wipeoff on the McKee’s was ok as far as ease, similar to how Colonite is to wipeoff. There’s a tad bit of tackiness as you’re wiping it off which once it’s buffed off leaves you with smooth paint, but nothing remarkable as far as smoothness, but personally that’s ok with me as long as it hopefully hits the mark in other areas.
About 4hrs. later it began to rain for about 4hrs. or so. Light rain… I didn’t go outside to take any pics that 1st night.
Yesterday/Saturday it was cloudy all morning and began to rain again at about 5pm. and continued all throughout the night. Pretty good strong rainfall.
I took these pics just after @1am.
The beading on both was a bit more pronounced on the 1st night of rain, but I didn’t take the time to take any pics. [not a crazy difference though]
McKee’s:
Armor All:
McKee’s:
Armor All:
We’re supposed to get several more days of rain coming up this week. I’ll keep you posted.
And I’ll say it again, if you’ve been using the same microfiber towels and have put them through lots of work, you should strongly consider demoting and replacing them with a new batch. They may look clean, and you might even believe they are because these new microfiber detergents are supposed to do a great job… But you might be surprised.

Don’t be El Cheapo for too long.