Dr_Pain
New member
- Nov 28, 2012
- 2,196
- 0
BOOK REVIEW
Right before SEMA, Bryan ran a contest and I was one of the prize recipients. The winnings were Mike Phillips How to use the Flex XC3401 book Link to contest! I did promise to read and review, and for all that know me, you know that I am true to my promises, and also fair and informative in my posts.
Here are a couple of pictures as the book sits on my desk. I had quite a few patients that dropped in and asked what I was reading LOL! The big surprised was that it was signed on the inside cover page. I was not expecting that! Thanks Mike.
The book can currently be purchased for $19.99 (on sale for $14.99) Mike Phillips' How to use the Flex XC3401 VRG Dual Action Orbital Polisher Paperback Book
EXPECTATIONS:
I've owned a Flex 3401 for a while and really came to love the polisher following hours and hours of polishing on all types of surfaces (two stage paint, single stage paint, gel coat and even glass). Prior to the Flex I worked with the GG6 and a Rupes 21. The Rupes has been my workhorse, until I found the Flex. Don't get me wrong the Rupes outperforms the Flex in certain task but my "brute force" polisher has been the Flex ever since I put my hands on it. Why am I telling you all of that? Because although I did perfect my craft through experimentation, I was looking forward to some expert wisedom to get even better with it. Having known Mike for a few years my expectations were high. We are dealing with one of the big name in the industry after all, right!?.
BOOK CONSTRUCTION
The book is a 52 page soft cover book which looks to use similar glossy paper as high end magazines. At first glance the book is full of well laid out pages combining written and visual material (colored pictures). I read a lot of dry technical/scientific writings so I always welcome a visually stimulating book. You can find a clearly delineated index in the front, which will help direct you to a section of interest. The font and size makes it easy to read and points of interests or emphasis are clearly defined with a change in font color and with bold terms (ie. IMPORTANT). It does appear that the physical book is simply a printed extension of the digital version as you have a lot of hyperlink (which obviously don't work. Trust me I tried LOL!). The writing style simple, concise and to the point, definitely something that everyone can read and follow (unlike some of my writings which at times requires you to re-read 10x because they are complex verbal regurgitation)
CONTENT
know I will get a lot of flack from my comments but I am sure that Mike will take my constructive criticisms for what they are, a way to improve on an existing product
The book itself is not an exposé on the Flex 3401 as much as it is an introductory to detailing. It does contain a little history on the company, a little about its construction, its differences when comparing to a free spindle model..... but then the book falls flat. You do get Mike's pad and compound recommendations; and recommendation for polisher speed; as well as Mike's wisdom with regards to maximizing our detailing profitability and marketing.... but all the information is very, very basic and does leave a seasoned detailer wanting more. I would not mind a "kindergarten" section if we could have a "PhD" section as well. As an outsider looking in, you can definitely see the PBMG influence in the product placement, however I cannot fault them for the cross promotion as I fully understand the "reach" of a book of that nature, especially if you are the publisher.
In any case, if you were to read the book without knowing the title you would swear that it was a basic intro to detailing (discussing pad selection, compound selection, pad priming, test spots, section passes), with a section on the Flex, so I fail to see a real "how to" on the actual Flex machine, except for the 5 pages that deal with the construction (gear driven mechanism), basic maintenance (felt lubrication), and aftermarkets (interchangeable backing plate).
As a detailer, I wanted to hear the "pearls of wisdom" on the machine and its advanced handling (i.e how to attack complex concavities, convexities, smaller areas like mirrors, with a lot more a lot more meat than what was presented in the "6 tips" section). It would also have been nice to read about mods and repair tips (common problems, problem shooting etc..). Even the recommendation for maintenance such lubrication frequency and what could make you want to lubricate more often (like polishing on gelcoat with a lot of downpressure) were left vague and basic. I know that most of the information I am seeking would be too technical for a book geared to the general public but what should you expect from a book entitled "How to use the Flex 3401"? When I buy new books I normally look for 2 things: 1) to confirm that I am doing ok 2) to learn new tips and tricks. Unfortunately for me this book didn't really offer either. Don't get me wrong, it is a very good book as an intro to detailing but I would doubt that it would do much for Mike's reputation to swap the section on the polisher (in the front of the book) to have a Rupes section and re-publish the same book as a "How to use the Rupes 21/15/Duetto"
RATING THE BOOK
Overall I would give the general content of the book a solid 7/10 if looking at it as a beginner detailer. This is definitely a book that will bring invaluable information to a person that never handled a polisher and wanted to start with the Flex. You may find the information a little flat if you are a "geeker" with a little experience as all of the information is referenced is a redundancy off of information shared regularly on the forum. I gave it a 7/10 over an 8/10 because having seen what the Nanoskin Autoscrub can do to paint using forced rotation (and lacking lubrication)... I would have definitely put a strong word of warning about using the Flex over a free spindle DA (which would stop if you made the mistake of not using enough lube). In addition, I would personally add that you need to do an IPA or Erasor wipedown to your test spot before confirming your process. Too many people (even more experienced detailers) are fooled by those polishing oils filling the marring/micro scratches
What about the rating of the book to a veteran detailer? I would give it a 2/10 (I know HARSH!!). It is definitely a fun easy read, but nothing new or earth shattering, and definitely not a "go-to" book. I will cherish my book since Mike signed it, but it will find its way to my memorabilia shelf alongside my Ivan bobble heads etc..
Please feel free to ask questions, comments etc...
. Glad to see you enjoyed it as well. I found it to be very informative and helped me with my technique and pad selection.
oke:
