HD speed vs Megs D166

Nice review! Thanks for posting!

As for me... I have no loyality. I'm only loyal to the product that I like. This is one I am definitely going to try. I could care less if a company makes 856 billion an hour or 1$ a day. If their product suits my needs then that's what I use!!!!
 
custmsprty said:
Hardly fair to little 3D in California...
Click to expand...
With you on small a local. I will go out of my way to buy small or local company products where I can, especially those who innovate. It drives my wife crazy.
 
mwoywod said:
Mind me asking why? Just curious what turned you off about 3D
Click to expand...

I rather not get into anymore. I'm not going to detract from the review Freddie has posted. The results speak for themselves.
 
The Guz said:
I rather not get into anymore. I'm not going to detract from the review Freddie has posted. The results speak for themselves.
Click to expand...
lol, you and my wife would get along. She also makes statements she knows will illicit a response, then once I try to talk to her and understand her problem....she wants to drop it. I'll say the same thing I say to her. Whatever you say, sweetheart.
 
WRAPT C5Z06 said:
Clearly, you're a 3D fanboy.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Detailing attracts fanboy infatuation for certain brands, products and methods. I'm a fanboy of Collinite, but I'm passive about it. Love the products but very open to try others. And my wax collection proved that I have already tried 20+ others. The counterpoint is aggressive fanboy loyalty which is exclusionary, jingoistic and hypersensitive to questioning and counterproductive in open forums like this. I really like 360 but it is the only AIO I have extensive experience with. In effect I'm clueless when it comes to AIO and freely admit it. My current supply of 360 is about 48 oz (1.5 bottles) so an alternative needs to be extremely compelling to get me to try it. HD is just not compelling enough. Megs is interesting but I need to use up more of what I have before buying another product to add to my sickness. I'm starting to run out of space.

There is more than one type of fanboy.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Great comparison. Thanks for putting it together


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
For sure, this product is poking is rattling some cages and not just here. It's also sparking some interesting options on the FB groups as well

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
 
Great that it works in direct sunlight, but should be even better in the shade or garage.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I love competition. With that said, doesn't say much for Meguire's coming out with a similar product. 3D HD Speed blew up and now the big dogs want a piece of the pie. 3D set a presidence and shook/rattled the detailing world. I'll stick to what I know works great, and that is HD Speed and Polish. Some of the easiest, cost effective products, I've had the luxuries of using. Thanks again 3D and keep up the good work! Capitalism at its finest...

Btw, yes, I am a 3D fanboy. ;)
 
MikeC78 said:
I love competition. With that said, doesn't say much for Meguire's coming out with a similar product. 3D HD Speed blew up and now the big dogs want a piece of the pie. 3D set a presidence and shook/rattled the detailing world. I'll stick to what I know works great, and that is HD Speed and Polish. Some of the easiest, cost effective products, I've had the luxuries of using. Thanks again 3D and keep up the good work! Capitalism at its finest...

Btw, yes, I am a 3D fanboy. ;)[/QUOTE

I have to respectfully disagree with you here. The way I see it is that 166 is a cleaner wax(or as we call it an AIO). 166 may me the latest and greatest refinement of an AIO product. HD speed is an modern AIO product also that's works rather well. But I'm pretty sure 3D didn't invent the AIO. I recall Megs having multiple AIO products on the market before 3D was even born.

Tha way I see it is that 166 is the latest version of an AIO and not trying to copy or take down HD Speed.
Click to expand...
 
Dr Oldz said:
I have to respectfully disagree with you here. The way I see it is that 166 is a cleaner wax(or as we call it an AIO). 166 may me the latest and greatest refinement of an AIO product. HD speed is an modern AIO product also that's works rather well. But I'm pretty sure 3D didn't invent the AIO. I recall Megs having multiple AIO products on the market before 3D was even born.

Tha way I see it is that 166 is the latest version of an AIO and not trying to copy or take down HD Speed.
Click to expand...

:goodpost: ... :xyxthumbs:


Bob
 
Don't put words in my mouth now.... I never said "3D invented anything". 3D refined an AIO like nobody has done before and therefore the competition did too. Hence, the reason Meg's came out with a similar like compound to compete.
 
Haven't used D166 yet but like the other guy said HD Speed works the best out of any AIO product that I have used and I have used prolly 75% of them Menzerna 3in1 sits right underneath HD Speed because Its correction ability isn't as quick an easy as HD Speed, any knuckle head can grab a buffer an pad and throw some HD Speed on it and make a vehicle look immaculate and that's gonna be a hard product to beat but I'm a huge fan of Meg's products And use them on a daily basis but competing with HD Speed is going to be a tuff egg to crack.


Sent from my iPhone using AGOnline
 
Dr Oldz said:
MikeC78 said:
I love competition. With that said, doesn't say much for Meguire's coming out with a similar product. 3D HD Speed blew up and now the big dogs want a piece of the pie. 3D set a presidence and shook/rattled the detailing world. I'll stick to what I know works great, and that is HD Speed and Polish. Some of the easiest, cost effective products, I've had the luxuries of using. Thanks again 3D and keep up the good work! Capitalism at its finest...

Btw, yes, I am a 3D fanboy. ;)[/QUOTE

I have to respectfully disagree with you here. The way I see it is that 166 is a cleaner wax(or as we call it an AIO). 166 may me the latest and greatest refinement of an AIO product. HD speed is an modern AIO product also that's works rather well. But I'm pretty sure 3D didn't invent the AIO. I recall Megs having multiple AIO products on the market before 3D was even born.

Tha way I see it is that 166 is the latest version of an AIO and not trying to copy or take down HD Speed.
Click to expand...

Hasn't Klasse' AIO been around since 1776 or earlier?
Click to expand...
 
Route246 said:
Dr Oldz said:
Hasn't Klasse' AIO been around since 1776 or earlier?
Click to expand...

Again, I never said 3D reinvented the wheel or an AIO. If you're comparing Klasse's AIO to HD Speed, than you might be stuck in the Stone Age. 3D clearly refined products and made them better. Just like any other product out there, to include coatings, there are many different competitors and they all push the envelope compared to the earlier years.
Click to expand...
 
MikeC78 said:
Route246 said:
Again, I never said 3D reinvented the wheel or an AIO. If you're comparing Klasse's AIO to HD Speed, than you might be stuck in the Stone Age. 3D clearly refined products and made them better. Just like any other product out there, to include coatings, there are many different competitors and they all push the envelope compared to the earlier years.
Click to expand...

I have no love lost for Klasse. I have written plenty of less-than-complimentary comments about Klasse in general here but put a muzzle on myself when it started going negative and contentious. I have two bottles I can't give away now to fellow detailer hobbyists in my area. They all know the reputation and want nothing to do this this antiquated product line. There are far better modern products out there.

You said it, I didn't, but I agree very strongly with your characterization, "...you might be stuck in the Stone Age..."

Regarding 3D, I have no opinion as I am satisfied with 360 and plenty of supply with no reason to try something new. I have no doubt it is a competent product and would never turn it down if someone offered it to me. That would be foolish on my part.
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top