Barkeater, I like arguing because it helps me learn. =)
The color difference is one of the reasons why that tree looks hazy.
First, the spar is thicker than OC or Olense. Hence the reason it can fill sanding marks where OC/Olens cannot. OC or Olens disappear shortly after application, they REACT with the substrate instead of just covering it up like the spar does. This extra depth of spar creates a layer that distorts the light being transmitted.
The problem with OC or OLens is that you need to be an auto-body technician to be able to sand it to the point of showing no sanding marks. I tried OLens(for $60) one time and sanded for almost 2 hours and still wasn't able to make it look good. I guess if I charged $100 a set and became an expert at sanding odd shaped lenses for 2 hours it would be great for me too.
I'm not sure if thicker Spar would cause as much or more distortion than several coats of clearcoat, but I'm guessing if you put enough coats of anything on .....there will be some distortion.
Second, The color. Just like if you are drinking fruit punch, if you have a little bit left in your cup then fill with water, your new water will have a slight hint of reddish color to it. If you spill that mixture next to pure water you probably wont notice the difference, but that doesn't mean its not there. And to those of us who do this for a living, we notice it and it affects the clarity of the lens without doubt.
Now if Spar was optically clear, like CLEAR COAT, I would agree that there is probably a negligble difference between the 2. But it is not clear. You cannot see the bottom of the can from the top by any means. But with clear coat you can, and i bet if you had a can of OC you could as well. The whole purpose of restoring headlights is to restore clarity, so why not use something thats CLEAR? Not just something that appears clear when thinned and spread out.. something that is actually clear!
As for the color.....Everything I've read and studied said that UV from the sun is the main cause for the lens coating to deteriorate in the first place. The color in the Spar IS the UV protectant. I'm not sure if the UV protection that is added to clearcoat has any color to it, but I would guess that it does.....and if you just use several coats of clear, then compare that to several coats of spar.
I'm not saying that spar is the best thing to use on headlights for long-term results, I'm just saying......each person has to try different things and use what works best for your application.
If you want to see evidence of OC being acid resistant, check out my other thread. I was skeptical too as you can read in this thread, but what happened 1-2 weeks after these pictures has me sold.
http://www.autogeekonline.net/forum/auto-detailing-101/66778-opti-coat-bird-poo-fail.html