Can't give you much advice without knowing what type of car you drive, what would you like to accomplish with the new tires. Do you go off-road, road tracks, street, etc.
tire rack consumer survey matrix is imo the best way to decide on tires.
Michelin PS A/S 3 are what i run on my tire eating Eurochard-tuned AMG and they are sensational. Michelin engineer told me that they are so close to PSS performance specifications with much greater characteristics - as an a/s that was all i needed to hear.