Need advice on garage scuffs

J

jsa

New member
Joined
May 20, 2017
Messages
14
Reaction score
0
My wife hit the side of her car on the garage and some advice on how to get the scuffs out. Here is my thoughts:

Porter Cable (speed setting 5/6)
Lake Country foam pads

White pad/McKees 360 if no..
White pad/McKees Fine Cut. Still no
White pad McKees Aggressive Compound

If still no, I would follow the same compound order only with an orange pad.

If still no, same compound order but with a yellow pad.

What are your thoughts?

Thanks, much appreciated​!

Sent from my XT1254 using Autogeekonline mobile app
 
jsa said:
My wife hit the side of her car on the garage and some advice on how to get the scuffs out. Here is my thoughts:

Porter Cable (speed setting 5/6)
Lake Country foam pads

White pad/McKees 360 if no..
White pad/McKees Fine Cut. Still no
White pad McKees Aggressive Compound

If still no, I would follow the same compound order only with an orange pad.

If still no, same compound order but with a yellow pad.

What are your thoughts?

Thanks, much appreciated​!

Sent from my XT1254 using Autogeekonline mobile app
Click to expand...
View attachment 57601

Sent from my XT1254 using Autogeekonline mobile app
 
You have a solid plan. Go forth and shine

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk
 
I would wash the area and then try clay first. I bet most of that will be removed by claying.


Sent from my iPhone using AGOnline
 
Mr Clean Magic Eraser first. My wife did the same and a few sprays of WD 40 and Magic Eraser got everything out super easy.
 
You've got a good plan, but getting hands on with some agressive clay will get you a better picture of what you are dealing with. I personally don't go near paint with a Magic Eraser but it should be ok on the trim.
 
It looks like simple paint transfer. Clay won't remove that. And I wouldn't go anywhere near paint with a Magic Eraser... Sounds like OP has the right plan in mind. [go straight to the Orange pad and it sound come off fairly quik, especially paired with the compound]
 
BSoares said:
Mr Clean Magic Eraser first. My wife did the same and a few sprays of WD 40 and Magic Eraser got everything out super easy.
Click to expand...


rlmccarty2000 said:
You've got a good plan, but getting hands on with some agressive clay will get you a better picture of what you are dealing with. I personally don't go near paint with a Magic Eraser but it should be ok on the trim.
Click to expand...

times 10 for the wd40 thats awful advice. Whether or not it works wd40 its not made for anything regarding paint issues on a car.
 
Just be careful around edges, that's where paint is the thinnest. What ever method you use and works, just be mindful and more careful around the edges.


Sent from my iPhone using AGOnline
 
I have to agree with all the warnings against using WD-40. WD-40 is a solvent and it nevers touches my car's paint. I would offer the same caution about using a Magic Eraser on paint. I still do not know what chemicals are in those things and not knowing that keeps them off my paint or any other use inside or outside the car. Yup, WD-40 and a magic eraser worked quickly but the harshness of both of those products scares me!

With regard to "scuffs" or any paint transfer type of vehicle "wound"...

I always treat them FIRST as something on top of the paint. That is, whatever was transferred onto my paint I like to remove with a decontamination type effort. If house paint has been rubbed onto my car paint it is first sitting on top of my paint. I always remove the unwanted transfer FIRST to then reveal whatever scratches have occurred BELOW the paint surface. My favorite is Duragloss 501 but I like any chemical type paint cleaner or cleaner wax without too much abrasive. For me, this cleans the unwanted house paint off first. I can then reveal if, and how deep, any scratches remain. Then I proceed to abrading the scratch(es) accordingly with the appropriate grade abrasive and pad. If any scratches are too deep, leave them alone and consider filling them in with paint or simply biting the bullet and get it professionally repaired. A clay bar may also be effective as you're working at getting something off the paint's surface.

My personal approach would be the chemical paint cleaner or cleaner wax product with an escalating progression of pad firmness if a mild pad doesn't get it. 90% of the time I'm happy with removing the ugliness once the transferred paint is gone. Then, I don't chase deep scratches with compounds that remove too much of that precious factory paint.

And all of this is like a test spot for me. I go least aggressive first to eventually arrive at what is most effective but removes the least amount, if any, of the factory applied paint.

Sorry that happened for ya, jsa, but after removing all that white paint it will look much better. From the pic it looks scratched too but try to minimize them if they're too deep.
 
Eldorado2k said:
It looks like simple paint transfer. Clay won't remove that.
Click to expand...

That has also been my experience that clay is ineffective in these circumstances. And also, as has been mentioned, polishes which are primarily chemical cleaners do well on house paint.

What no one else seems to have mentioned, is, to me, from the picture, it looks like several areas are through the paint. So the OP needs to be aware that once he removes the house paint that is "on top", as previously mentioned, and smooths it out a little, he is going to be left with areas of exposed primer and possibly metal, which if he attempts to "remove", are only going to get worse.
 
Absolutely agree, setec! Once it's cleaned up and you are left with whatever damage remains, you need to make sure to recognize what you can't do anything about.
 
Well, I went through the entire process that I outlined and wouldn't you know it, it took the last option. Yellow pad, aggressive compound. Wife thinks I'm a hero, so it was worth it. Thanks guys for your help!

Sent from my XT1254 using Autogeekonline mobile app
 
jsa said:
Well, I went through the entire process that I outlined and wouldn't you know it, it took the last option. Yellow pad, aggressive compound. Wife thinks I'm a hero, so it was worth it. Thanks guys for your help!

Sent from my XT1254 using Autogeekonline mobile app
Click to expand...

now here's your chance to order more detail supplies and let her know that just in case "something like this happens again"... ;)
 
...or do like I did, paint the garage walls the same color as her car!!!
 
VISITOR said:
now here's your chance to order more detail supplies and let her know that just in case "something like this happens again"... ;)
Click to expand...
Good point! There's A LOT of good stuff to purchase from Autogeek, I should make a father's day wish list! She owes me!

Sent from my XT1254 using Autogeekonline mobile app
 
I just had a conversation at work with a couple other guys about their wives doing this exact thing. OMG is it every woman?????
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top